CONTROVERSIAL plans for a Co-op supermarket in Coggeshall have been rejected.

The firm wanted to demolish and redevelop the former Fleetshield garage, in East Street, to replace its store at Doubleday Corner.

Braintree Council turned down the application – despite officers recommending approval of the scheme, which would have created 40 jobs.

A petition of more than 200 signatures was sent to the council. Villagers’ concerns included the impact on other shops, inadequate access and parking, extra traffic and the store attracting antisocial behaviour.

Essex Police were concerned there were not enough crime prevention measures, such as external lighting and a barrier to stop the car park being used out of hours.

The council also received 22 letters of support, including from Coggeshall Parish Council and English Heritage.

Retail consultant Bruce Hartley-Raven said a bigger Co-op would persuade residents to spend more in village shops, from £2.2million to £4.4million a year.

Mr Hartley-Raven said there was no evidence shops such as Spar, Martins newsagents or the Post Office would be affected, but specialist store Buntings foodstore and butchers would be at most threat.

Paul Woolston, from Buntings, who objected to the application, said: “If the Co-op wanted to prove it is a caring company, it should improve the store it has got. We are a small community, so if they stop selling things that compete with other retailers, everyone gains.”

The council planning committee’s reasons for refusal included the fact there was no mention of external lighting; concern over noise and traffic and the lack of evidence to prove the development would not affect the vitality of other shops.

The Co-op, which has permission to expand at Doubleday Corner, could appeal. Spokesman Nick Denny said: “We are disappointed. We are reviewing our options.”