Residents share struggles on BBC report on Essex estate

Deprived - Magnolia in Greenstead  named as one of the most deprived areas in England <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
Deprived - Magnolia in Greenstead named as one of the most deprived areas in England (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A REPORT looking at life in Greenstead has called one-sided view after it focused on poverty in the area.

BBC Radio 4’s Today programme interviewed residents on the estate as part of a study looking at challenges people face.

But councillors for the ward said they were not asked to take part and said the broadcast failed to reflect the area’s strengths.

Journalists visited Greenstead, which has repeatedly been named one of the most deprived places in Britain, to speak to people on the streets.

The report said: “Poverty here is of two kinds, both unforgiving. Those who don’t work and increasingly those who do.”

The broadcast explored the changing nature of work in the area, stating: “The old trades and factories that industrious workers left school to make a living from have gone, replaced by service and delivery jobs.”

Residents also spoke about the pressures of the cost of living.

One mother of six said her household survives on benefits but struggles to cover essential expenses.

“Probably about two and a half grand a month,” she said, before adding when asked if it was enough:

“Not at all… electric a week going for £100 a week on electric, and gas is, obviously, the winter, that’s expensive… I can do two, £300 a month at Iceland, and then I still have to go to Tesco’s for other bits that I need weekly daily… I go through about 12 pints of milk a day.”

The report also highlighted pressures on local services, including schools.

It said some children are placed on reduced timetables, explaining: “So you’ve got primary and secondary school age children being sent home from school… it meant to be educating at home, but obviously some of the parents can’t… they’re probably meeting others and they’re probably getting in trouble.”

Greenstead Community Centre (Image: Steve Brading)

At the same time, the programme noted the role of support networks, describing the community centre as “like a kind of a hub in the whole community where people can come, it’s safe, and they get life-changing advice, companionship, connection, and information.”

However, Greenstead ward councillor Tim Young has criticised the broadcast, saying it presented a one-sided view.

Mr Young said he was not contacted during the making of the report.

He said: “They said they didn’t want to speak to any politicians because of the elections. But we’re not in the election period yet.

"I must admit I wasn't impressed with the report.

“I thought it was a very unbalanced, negative piece about Greenstead with none of the positives emphasised at all. I was very disappointed. In fact, I’ve sent a voicemail to the producer complaining and asking for a right of reply.”

He added that the report failed to reflect improvements and investment in the area.

He added: “There’s a wonderful community spirit in Greenstead. The schools are doing much better. They sort of concentrate on some negatives about Colchester Academy.

"But all its recent Ofsted reports have been good. It’s now got good numbers going. The results are improving. Attendance is improving, behaviour is improving. None of that was mentioned."

Greenstead has also been give a shared of millions of pounds over the next 10 years plus the Heart of Greenstead project.

Mr Young added: “We’re the only area with a local housing office. We’ve got a thriving library and, you know, you would have thought from the report that it was a really poor place, that hadn’t got any facilities, which is just not true.

“All the people here are very proud of living in Greenstead. There’s great community spirit and I just thought it was a very unfair representation of the place I’ve represented for 34 years.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos