Mural plan for Holy Trinity Church in Colchester rejected

Lion Walk Shopping Centre’s bid to create the mural on the external side of a wall at Holy Trinity Church, in Church Street, have been unanimously rejected by the planning committee.

Councillors agreed with planning officers and Historic England the mural was inappropriate for the historic church site, which is the oldest surviving building in Colchester.

John Burton, a conservation architect and president of Colchester Civic Society, spoke at the meeting in opposition to the plan.

He said: “Even though the mural is proposed on a wall of little architectural feature, the wall is none the less in planning law, part of the Grade I listed building.

“Should you disagree with your officer or be persuaded by others to grant permission you could open the doors to owners of all grades of listed buildings in Colchester arguing painting the building the colour they like, or with murals, or even advertising is no different to the approval you gave on Trinity Church, a Grade I listed building.

“We understand the applicants did not consult Heritage England or yourselves before this application was made.

“May we encourage Colchester Council and the applicants to get together to determine places which need beautifying which will be of benefit to both the town and the shopping area.”

“Members of the Civics Society would be prepared to work with both parties if they wished.”

Read more:

• Manager hits back over plans to transform ‘dull’ wall into mural
• Colourful mural could be created in Colchester town centre
• 5 months of overnight closures planned for A12 in Essex

Daisy Lees, of Art Eat Events, asked the committee to approve the application with a caveat consultation would then take place on the design.

She said: “Bringing visual art and culture to the centre of towns and cities is proven to increase footfall, prolong visit time, increase interest and tourism.

“We are happy to be employed by Lion Walk Shopping Centre to lead this project, which is supported by businesses, shopkeepers and residents and will brighten up a central part of Colchester, educate and entertain passersby about the historical context of the site.”

The wall where the mural was set to be created

Committee members said the mural was in the wrong place.

Chairwoman Pauline Hazell said: “I think it is in the wrong place.

“It is an ancient church and of itself we should celebrate that and find ways we can truly enhance the area with the church as the centre piece.”