Forum Colchester holds packed debate on the monarchy

Debaters - (L-R) Fred Mulligan, Kristina Bhrava, Neil D'Arcy Jones, William Hagerup and Nicholas Tavera Urdininea <i>(Image: Anna Sophie Hagerup.)</i>
Debaters - (L-R) Fred Mulligan, Kristina Bhrava, Neil D'Arcy Jones, William Hagerup and Nicholas Tavera Urdininea (Image: Anna Sophie Hagerup.)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A lively public debate saw a full audience return to a popular pub for its latest event.

The community debate by Forum Colchester, tackled the provocative motion: “This House Would Abolish The Monarchy.”

The discussion took place at the historic Queen Street Brewhouse, a 14th-century pub known for its Belgian beer selection, which once again provided a packed and attentive setting for the evening’s arguments.

The event opened with co-founder Andrew McDonald outlining the group’s aim to create a space for respectful and structured engagement with complex ideas.

Forum Colchester Monarchy debateDebaters - (L-R) Fred Mulligan, Kristina Bhrava, Neil D'Arcy Jones, William Hagerup and Nicholas Tavera Urdininea (Image: Anna Sophie Hagerup.)

Mr McDonald emphasised the importance of civil discourse at a time of increasing public polarisation, a theme echoed throughout the evening.

Chairing the debate, Neil D’Arcy-Jones invited attendees to cast a preliminary vote before proceedings began.

The audience showed a clear initial preference against the motion, with a 12–4 majority opposing abolition of the monarchy and several abstentions.

Audience - The Queen Street Brewhouse was packed with attendees (Image: Anna Sophie Hagerup.)

Speaking in favour of the motion were seasoned debaters Fred Mulligan and Kristina Bhrava, while opposition speakers included William Hagerup and Nicholas Tavera Urdininea.

Following a wide-ranging exchange of arguments, a second vote was held at the conclusion of the debate.

The opposition increased its support by four votes, while the proposition gained two, resulting in the motion being defeated.

Announcement - Andrew McDonald introduced the debate (Image: Anna Sophie Hagerup.)

Artistic director of Colchester's open air theatre, Mr D’Arcy-Jones thanked the speakers, attendees, and pub landlord, Andy Skene for hosting.

He also highlighted upcoming community events including Theatre in the Park activities scheduled for June.

Mr Hagerup announced the next Forum Colchester debate will take place on Sunday June 28, with a more local focus: “This House Says No More New Homes in Colchester!”

Residents interested in attending are encouraged to follow Forum Colchester on social media or check listings for the Queen Street Brewhouse to reserve a place.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos